A Network of Networks, Unfazed by Censorship

Much has been written about the role of the internet in Tunisia and Egypt. One thing is certain: The internet is becoming harder to censor. It is a network of networks that connects online and offline and provides a lifeline to the outside world.

It is hard to turn on the news these days without hearing a discussion of the role of social media in the recent events in the Middle East. But what our research tells us, first and foremost, is that we won’t have a clear picture of this until the dust settles, and the data is collected and analyzed. Last year’s so-called Twitter Revolution in Iran ultimately proved to be neither a revolution nor twitter-driven upon careful analysis of the activity on that platform.

We also know from our research that any insightful analysis of social media’s role requires disentangling the different channels (blogs, tweets, facebook, tv, print) as well as different levels of activism — individual, group, inter-group, and regime. In other words, it’s complicated and, next week in Silicon Valley, USIP is bringing together an array of some of the best researchers on the Internet and social media with the companies themselves (Facebook, YouTube, Ebay, Google etc.) to try and unpack the incredible events of the last few months.

A complicated picture

So that’s what our research has told us – don’t rush to judgment about the role of technology in anything as complex as political and social change. Undoubtedly, what we’ve seen across the last few months is a function of people and passion first and foremost, rather than any particular technology platform.

At the same time, I want to call out the voices of the activists themselves – whether it’s Wael Ghonim, the Google executive who was jailed for helping to organize the protests in Egypt, or Ai Wei Wei in China who was also jailed for his activism – their answer is unequivocal: the Internet is an absolutely key enabler of their efforts to drive social change. Its social networks are part of a vast web of instantaneous information lines into and out of these countries that connects the protesters to each other and to the outside world in the run-up to the street protests.

And if these networks, communicating via the Internet and mobile phones, weren’t so critical, you can be sure that the government would not have hit the “kill switch” the way it did in Egypt. This was really unprecedented. In virtually every other case of new media-connected movements – Tunisia, Iran, for example – the governments were much more moderated in cutting off access, slowing things down, opening them back up, slowing them down. Egypt really was the first of its kind, in terms of near total blackout for a couple of days – raising all sorts of worrying questions.

Protesting and media coverage never stopped

But the fact remains – the protesting never stopped nor did the media coverage of events. The flow of information continued, due in some measure to these social networks, since what’s at work here is really a network of networks. Some are more vulnerable than others – especially where most people, as in Egypt, rely on the large centralized services like Gmail or Twitter which in fact are quite easy for the governments to impede.

But the Internet is strikingly resilient because at its core it is, as I said, this network of networks. So activists quickly figure out innovative work-arounds. And if you followed social media across the Middle East protests you saw this happening – reports from inside Egypt delivered via third party proxies —to continually enable communication with the outside world, as well among the activists themselves. For those on the ground, trying to change history, the Internet and social media was a vital lifeline.

Read more in this debate: Firas Al-Atraqchi, Jillian York, Jeffrey Carr.

Comments

comments powered by Disqus

From the debate

An Internet Revolution?

On Twitter, An Energized Public Sphere

Big_f1e46ff034

While no medium of mass communication can create the conditions and variables that compound into revolution, social media has served as the catalyst which has helped weiter...

Small_9060817aa1
by Firas Al-Atraqchi
11.02.2011

Blood, Sweat and Tear Gas

Big_d69985c94e

The internet has developed an impressive effect from Teheran to Tunis. Nevertheless, we should not speak of social media revolutions. 140 characters have never brought down a dictator.

Small_27e97a99b9
by Jillian York
05.02.2011

Trapped in the Net

Big_5988901038

Social Media is a double-edged sword. The internet has facilitated the communication among dissidents in Tunisia and Egypt. But governments are learning its value as well. weiter...

Small_ef8debece5
by Jeffrey Carr
04.02.2011
Most Read